Pets & Veganism: Should Animal-lovers Have Pets?
ancamonica
. . .
Your go-to app for all things vegan
Responses
Earthling Ed has done a few talks on this subject and it’s really interesting! I think that living with a pet can be a mutually beneficial relationship (especially if that pet has been rescued from an otherwise unsatisfactory or unsafe life). Unlike eating meat, where that is only beneficial to the human. Obviously supporting puppy mills and breeders doesn’t align with vegan ethics, but I think that rescuing/adopting an animal to provide them with a better life can be vegan. Also Ed has a podcast on the pet food industry (he addresses the “does feeding my pet meat make me less vegan” question). It’s really eye-opening!
REPLYBut you're still using an animal for a purpose rather than allowing them to freely live their own lives and make their own choices. I feel like this is a slightly complex issue in that there are domesticated animals that can't survive in the wild that need caretakers but the real issue is that they exist in the first place. And I don't think that adopting animals and using them as emotional support or human relationship replacements really does either party any favors.
REPLY@safariveg no, an animal's nutrition it's not a personal choice. They have to eat what they have to eat, naturally, in order to have an optimal health.
REPLYFor me this conversation is pretty cut and dry. A main principle of veganism, for me, is all about to whom I'm giving my money. As we all know, mainstream dog and cat food are loaded with animal parts, byproducts of the factory farm and other animal exploitation industries. A vegan doesn't give their money to that, therefore they shouldn't purchase it for their pet. There are more and more vegan dog food brands emerging that make it possible to feed a pet dog without unsuitable allergies. Seems the same can't be said for cats. I hate to promote ownership of other animals, but there are several herbivorous animals who fit a vegan lifestyle, if that animal is in need of a caring home and guardian. So, the conversation of ethics of animal ownership aside, vegans have options for having an animal companion.
REPLYI work with dogs. Absolutely love them, and I'd love to have a couple doggo friends living with me but I'm very nervous about them not acclimating to vegan dog food. It's such a risk. So, unless there's a dog shelter somewhere feeding its residents vegan food, I don't think it'd be responsible of me to adopt assuming things will be fine.
REPLYI wholeheartedly agree with everything that's been said here, however, and I apologize for being "that" person, but this happens to be my field of expertise and thus I feel it's my obligation to inform you - we did not tame wild wolves and teach them to hunt for us. The progression from wild wolf to tame dog was very much a gradual, natural process of evolution, which we then realized we could take advantage of, and then we interfered and things spun out of control VERY quickly into the situation we have today. The sheer volume of animals that are now dependent on us and also severely suffering because of us is repulsive and we do need to take responsibility and help them, there's absolutely no arguing that!
REPLYQuestion: If we hypotetically agreeded that pets must return gradually to their old habits and ancient instincts, could this be done? For example, firstly we could (in a perfect society) let them choose wether if they prefer to sleep in a house or any other place, and the cities would been provided by food and water for them (in a safe environment with no cars, etc) and approach them into more and more natural environments until they learn again their own individuality and survival skills.
REPLYUnfortunately, no. There is a lot we can do as a species to make the world a better place and to help alleviate the suffering wr have caused so far. But we can never ever go back to the way things were before. You cannot "unevolutionize" a species. They would have to go extinct, and even then, their impact would have already affected the world in some significant way, and so would their extinction. It sounds like a simple change or solution, but every single action has a ripple effect and causes a chain of reactions. We can never go backwards, only forwards!
REPLYAdopt pets, do not make them breed, let them gradually go extinct. It is a sad fate for a sentient being to be born with a body programmed to be our slaves.
REPLYWonderful article about a non very commented but still important topic :)). Yet still this brings me some questions. Should we adopt those animals until the end of their days so as to pay our debt with nature, and finishing with them the pet world? Like, should we end up with pets at all? The second one is, are all pets equally ethical? Some people have complained about me for this. I come from a rural area and there dogs can develop their natural faucets. Dogs run, hunt, play and bark. However in the city dogs stay quiet, do tricks and live in flats. Is it moral having a dog in a flat? I think they should ban it
REPLYThere are many studies that prove that dogs can thrive on a plant based diet. My dogs are vegan since puppies and are really healthy. No more allergies for one of them. Their veterinary studies are perfect. They eat The Green Dog and I can’t stop recommending it because I see the results. Cruelty free, eco friendly and finally complete and balanced pet food.
REPLY